r/SEO • Weekly Digest
The r/SEO community grapples with fundamental challenges around new site ranking, backlink strategy, and Google's evolving algorithms. AI automation in SEO sparks skepticism, with experienced practitioners warning against misguided implementations like llms.
Contractor seeks guidance on building 50 near-identical location-based landing pages, concerned about Google flagging them as doorway pages or spam. Core tension between client demands and SEO best practices regarding duplicate content and indexation risk.
20-year veteran debunks llms.txt as a fraudulent 'standard' with zero adoption by major LLMs. Sharp critique of AI-washing in SEO services, warning against practitioners who rebrand hype as innovation.
Personal case study of one-year optimization yielding minimal results, then breakthrough in year two. Documents the frustration of following SEO best practices without seeing returns, validating the 'SEO takes time' mantra through real experience.
Critical analysis of AI-generated SEO advice, highlighting how LLMs perpetuate false signals (E-E-A-T formatting, generic best practices) divorced from actual Google ranking factors. Exposes the gap between what AI recommends and SEO reality.
Niche dictionary site experiencing zero traffic despite ranking #1 for hundreds of searches—Google and AI bots scrape definitions directly into SERPs. Illustrates emerging challenge of AI-powered search eliminating need for users to click through.
Server-side tracking advocate questions Google Analytics accuracy, citing privacy concerns and GDPR friction. Argues for proprietary analytics based on intimate page knowledge rather than third-party tools.
New SEO practitioner bewildered by competitors accumulating 9K-137K backlinks on months-old sites while struggling with 200. Questions legitimacy of competitor link profiles and appropriate strategies for new sites.
Experienced practitioner soliciting real-world examples of high-impact SEO tactics for new sites, explicitly rejecting theory in favor of practical experience. Indicates frustration with generic advice.
New site owner following standard SEO practices (weekly posts, backlinks, keyword research, EEAT) experiencing rankings that disappear after 1-2 weeks. Represents common frustration with content not holding positions.
4-year link building professional with enterprise experience offering insights on guest posts, insertions, agency relationships, and budget strategies. Rare insider perspective from corporate SEO team.
Reddit, Inc. © 2025